Hello Dr. Schloss
Thank you so much for responding to this post. Apologies for the delay in replying I was trying to make sure I’d tried my best at the analysis myself. I was able to complete the tutorial without many problems. However, I am completely stuck with my data. I have tried many things but I am still stuck at the make.contigs process.
Firstly, I tried “make.contigs(ffastq=SAM1-16_S1_L001_R1_001.fastq, rfastq=SAM1-16_S1_L001_R2_001.fastq, oligos=oligos.txt, trimoverlap=T, processors=8)”.
However, this still could not make group files and the process in Mothur seemed to just contain numbers unlike the example data. The oligos file I used had the f primer, reverse primer and barcode “letters” and Sample ID. I tried some variations of the oligos file to try change this with F primer, R primer, Barcode “letters” and NONE and Sample ID. This came back saying "barcodes must be paired unless you are using an index file. I tried with F primer, R primer, barcode “letters” “same letters” and Sample ID. This created a group file but contained only 74 groups.
I realise that maybe my problem is that I was using just the forward and reverse read? So I tried make a stability file with the Sample ID in Column 1, Name of forward read in Column 2, Name of reverse read in Column 3, Index file in Column 4.
“make.contigs(file=stabilityfive.file, oligos=oligos.txt, trimoverlap=T, processors=8)”
Using 8 processors.
Reading fastq data…
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.I.DNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.I.cDNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S2_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S2_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.S1.DNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S3_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S3_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.S1.cDNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S4_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S4_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.S2.DNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S5_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S5_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.S2.cDNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S6_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S6_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.S5.DNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S7_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S7_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.S5.cDNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S8_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S8_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.E.DNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S9_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S9_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.E.cDNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S10_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S10_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.FE.DNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S11_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S11_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R1.FE.cDNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S12_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S12_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R2.Day.531.DNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S13_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S13_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R2.Day.531.cDNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S14_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S14_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R3.Day.531.DNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S15_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S15_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find R3.Day.531.cDNA, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S16_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S16_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
Done.
So I tried change the stability file to contain the forward fastq, reverse fast q, index filef, and NONE. This caused a different error.
make.contigs(file=stabilitysix.file, oligos=oligos.txt, trimoverlap=T, processors=8)
Using 8 processors.
Reading fastq data…
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S2_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S2_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S3_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S3_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S4_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S4_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S5_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S5_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S6_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S6_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S7_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S7_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S8_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S8_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S9_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S9_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S10_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S10_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S11_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S11_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S12_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S12_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S13_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S13_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S14_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S14_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S15_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S15_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S16_L001_R1_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: can’t find SAM1-16_S16_L001_R2_001.fastq, ignoring pair.
[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1112:12727:25543 expected a name with @ as a leading character, ignoring read.
[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2104:6417:17827 expected a name with + as a leading character, ignoring.[WARNING]: names do not match. read >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1112:12727:25543 for fasta and >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2104:6417:17827 for quality, ignoring.[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1111:14266:8949 expected a name with @ as a leading character, ignoring read.
[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1111:22516:16261 expected a name with + as a leading character, ignoring.[WARNING]: names do not match. read >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1111:14266:8949 for fasta and >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1111:22516:16261 for quality, ignoring.[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1113:14977:4917 expected a name with @ as a leading character, ignoring read.
[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1111:8257:15609 expected a name with + as a leading character, ignoring.[WARNING]: names do not match. read >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1113:14977:4917 for fasta and >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1111:8257:15609 for quality, ignoring.[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2106:24418:25790 expected a name with @ as a leading character, ignoring read.
[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1113:13459:23472 expected a name with + as a leading character, ignoring.[WARNING]: names do not match. read >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2106:24418:25790 for fasta and >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1113:13459:23472 for quality, ignoring.[WARNING]: Lengths do not match for sequence >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2106:24418:25790. Read 282 characters for fasta and 300 characters for quality scores, ignoring read.[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2107:17079:21072 expected a name with @ as a leading character, ignoring read.
[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2106:18041:21540 expected a name with + as a leading character, ignoring.[WARNING]: names do not match. read >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2107:17079:21072 for fasta and >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2106:18041:21540 for quality, ignoring.[WARNING]: Lengths do not match for sequence >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2107:17079:21072. Read 300 characters for fasta and 291 characters for quality scores, ignoring read.[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2101:15331:27248 expected a name with @ as a leading character, ignoring read.
[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2102:19304:20673 expected a name with + as a leading character, ignoring.[WARNING]: names do not match. read >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2101:15331:27248 for fasta and >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2102:19304:20673 for quality, ignoring.[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1111:7152:16001 expected a name with @ as a leading character, ignoring read.
[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2111:23748:26157 expected a name with + as a leading character, ignoring.[WARNING]: names do not match. read >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1111:7152:16001 for fasta and >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2111:23748:26157 for quality, ignoring.[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2106:16051:9557 expected a name with @ as a leading character, ignoring read.
[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2108:16030:10132 expected a name with + as a leading character, ignoring.[WARNING]: names do not match. read >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2106:16051:9557 for fasta and >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2108:16030:10132 for quality, ignoring.[WARNING]: Lengths do not match for sequence >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2106:16051:9557. Read 301 characters for fasta and 300 characters for quality scores, ignoring read.[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2111:15388:9731 expected a name with @ as a leading character, ignoring read.
[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1105:5705:13404 expected a name with + as a leading character, ignoring.[WARNING]: names do not match. read >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2111:15388:9731 for fasta and >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1105:5705:13404 for quality, ignoring.[WARNING]: Lengths do not match for sequence >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2111:15388:9731. Read 301 characters for fasta and 300 characters for quality scores, ignoring read.[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1109:23481:7800 expected a name with @ as a leading character, ignoring read.
[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1107:8980:15947 expected a name with + as a leading character, ignoring.[WARNING]: names do not match. read >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1109:23481:7800 for fasta and >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1107:8980:15947 for quality, ignoring.[WARNING]: Lengths do not match for sequence >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:1109:23481:7800. Read 300 characters for fasta and 282 characters for quality scores, ignoring read.[WARNING]: reading >M01522:110:000000000-A4LP7:1:2101:19362:13304 expected a name with @ as a leading character, ignoring read.
Which continued for so long I’d to quit the program!
I’m not sure where the errors could be coming from maybe my stability file or index file is wrong? I think part of the problem is I only have one R1 file and one R2 file from MR DNA containing all the files. But I don’t have individual fastq files. Are these something I need to make myself? The company carried out taxonomic analysis for us in QIIME so I have full fasta and qual files also. We needed to do some extra analysis which is why I’ve started working with the raw data in Mothur unfortunately nobody in our group has prior experience…
Your help is greatly appreciated, (or anyone else who will hopefully read this)
Best wishes,
Ciara Keating
Microbial Ecology Laboratory,
Microbiology Department
National University of Ireland, Galway
Ireland